Bagels From Scratch: Yes, You Totally Can

Bagels From Scratch: Yes, You Totally Can
Share this post with someone you love...Buffer this pageShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on StumbleUponPin on PinterestPrint this page

It’s amazing to me that a pile of flour, yeast, water, sugar, and salt can turn into so many different kinds of bread type things. Today, we’re going to use this pile of goodness to make bagels from scratch.

FARM bagel dough

Mmmm. Homemade bagels made from scratch.

Yes, you totally can do it. And it’s only going to take you a little over a couple hours from start to finish. Here’s how:

Bagels from Scratch – Ingredients:

4 1/4 to 4 1/2 cups flour

2 pkgs yeast (or 4 1/2 tsp bulk yeast – this is my favorite kind!)

1 1/2 cups warm water (about 110 degrees)

3 Tbsp sugar

1 Tbsp salt

Bagels from Scratch – Procedure:

In a big bowl, combine 1 1/2 cups of the flour and all of the yeast. In a smaller bowl, combine the water, sugar, and salt, and then add this mixture to the flour and yeast in the big bowl. Beat three minutes or so with a mixer at high speed.

Stir in more flour (by hand) to make a moderately thick dough, then turn out onto a lightly floured surface to knead until smooth.

(Kneading should take you 8-10 minutes. Don’t wimp out.)

Now, cover the dough with a dishtowel and let it (and yourself) rest for about 15 minutes.

After resting, cut the dough into 12 portions. Shape those portions into smooth balls and then punch a hole in the middle of each ball. Pull at the center of the hole you’ve punched to form a bigger hole.

Try to make your future bagels sorta kinda uniform likeβ€”let me know if you’re an expert at this, because I’m sorta kinda not.

Bagels from scratch A Farmish Kind of Life

After you have them all bagel-shaped, cover them with a towel again for another 20 minute rest.

While you’re resting, start a big pot of water with 1 gallon of water and 1 Tbsp sugar to boil. (Seriously. You will see why in a minute.)

After the 20 minute rest (and once your water is boiling), turn your water down to a simmer.

You are now going to drop those baby bagels into the water, four at a time, and let them simmer for seven minutes.

Bagels from Scratch A Farmish Kind of Life

You can turn them once while they are simmering.

I know: bread dough into water is weird. But do it anyway. Also, don’t forget to turn the water down to simmer, because if you actually boil these baby bagels…well…you will have to explain to your family why that batch didn’t turn out.

Ask me how I know.

You might also enjoy… Honey Wheat Bread: Perfect for Sandwiches

After seven minutes, pull them out of the water, and let them drain on a cooling rack.

Start the next four bagels in the water and repeat until all the bagels have had a nice warm bath.

Place all 12 of your bathed bagels on a greased baking sheet, and bake them at 375 for 30-35 minutes. And then…

Bagels from Scratch A Farmish Kind of Life

You might want to try one before your family knows they are done so you actually get one, because once they figure out the bagels from scratch are done, they will disappear.

Bagels from Scratch a Farmish Kind of Life

Yum-a-licious. πŸ™‚

(Recipe adapted from Better Homes and Garden Homemade Bread Cookbook.)

Spending time in the kitchen today? You could also make…

Homemade Hamburger Buns

Carrot Pie: Yes, I’m Serious

One Rise Baguette: Fast and Fancy

Pizza: Make Your Own From Scratch

What's better than bagels? Bagels from scratch. Here's how you can learn to make bagels from scratch like a boss. Own your kitchen, and possibly the world.


Do you homeschool? So do we! Check out my book β€” The Homeschool Highway: How to Navigate Your Way Without Getting Carsick.

That whole frugal living thing? It's not about money....except when it is. Check out my new book!

Want to keep up with what's happening in the barn, the kitchen, and the garden in my Farmish Kind of Life? Sign up and I'll help to make your inbox farmishly fantabulous. *
* Without spam. Because spam is horrible. And totally un-farmish.
Share this post with someone you love...Buffer this pageShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on StumbleUponPin on PinterestPrint this page

15 thoughts on “Bagels From Scratch: Yes, You Totally Can”

  • Just got a glimpse of your site, you are awesome. I am going to try the green beans tomorrow, maybe the bagels on Thursday when it rains. Looking forward to reading more. Thanks for sharing

    • I’ve not tried it, but my educated guess is that if you do half white half wheat, it would be fine. I’m not sure about using all wheat. If you try it, let me know how it works! πŸ™‚

  • Love these! Make them this morning. mine only took about 25 minutes in the oven. Thanks so much for sharing your recipe. My husband loves them!

  • Looove these! Made them for the first time last weekend when I had family visiting. They were a hit! This week I added blueberries to half of the batch and will put cinnamon sugar on the other half. I found that poking the hole in the dough balls, and the twirling them around on my finger makes them a LITTLE nicer looking than when I created the hole by stretching the hole out. Does that make sense?? Thank you for sharing this recipe!

  • Made these today. Outstanding! I added savory flavorings…onion flakes, garlic powder, dill weed, sea salt and fresh cracked black pepper to my dough. Very, very delicious.

  • Just made your bagels this morning and oh my goodness……… I’m in heaven. My Dad would be proud of me. He was the bread Baker once he retired. He would LOVE these. Thank you for sharing.. Brave enough to venture into other avenues of bread baking now.

  • Did you use regular or quick yeast? I assume quick as it rested only 15 minutes but how would the recipe vary for regular yeast?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *