Easy Homemade Pie Recipes You’ll Actually Want to Make
A Farmish Kind of Life is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. You can view our full affiliate disclosure here.
You ever find yourself in the mood to bake, and then spend 17 minutes trying to remember all your homemade pie recipes, and if it was the French Apple Pie that had the brown sugar crumble, or if the Hillbilly Buttermilk Pie was the one that weirdly tasted like vanilla custard heaven?
SAME, my friends.
So I finally pulled my favorite homemade pie recipes together for us. These six Farmish-approved pies have been made and enjoyed a zillion times in my kitchen. Print this out. Bookmark it. Make them all. You won’t regret it.
1. Homemade Fresh Strawberry Pie Recipe
This is that fresh, glazy, summer pie that screams picnic. Also a great pie to make when the discount grocery store randomly has cases of strawberries that need to be used NOW. Easy to throw together and so good you’ll forget you meant to share it.
Oh hey, and if homemade pie crust feels a little intimidating, this step-by-step guide from King Arthur Baking will walk you through some flaky perfection.
2. Crustless Pumpkin Pie – A Simple Homemade Favorite
For the folks who love the filling more than the crust (Husband, I’m looking at you). Also great for people who simply can’t eat traditional pie crust. This recipe is rich, cozy, and no one has to know you didn’t make a pie crust from scratch
3. Strawberry Rhubarb Pie – Sweet, Tart, and Totally Homemade
Sweet meets tart in a glorious flaky crust. This one tastes like spring on a plate and smells like your grandma’s kitchen. Probably.
4. Hillbilly Buttermilk Pie – The Homemade Classic You Didn’t Know You Needed
Don’t let the name fool you. This thing is sweet, smooth, and tastes like a mix between a chess pie and vanilla custard. Weirdly good. Wildly underrated.
5. French Apple Pie – A Farm Favorite
This is the pie you bring to the church potluck when you want everyone to talk about it later. Crumb topping, brown sugar, cinnamon… basically autumn in dessert form. But completely acceptable to eat in any season.
6. Carrot Pie – This Dessert Will Surprise You
Yes, carrot. Yes, it’s a pie. No, it doesn’t taste like carrot cake. It’s amazing and it will convert even the most skeptical of eaters. Trust me.
Whether you’re baking for a holiday, a crowd, or just because a random Tuesday needs a little extra awesome, these homemade pie recipes have you covered.
Try one. Try all six. (I won’t judge.) Tell me which is your favorite. And let me know if I’ve missed the world’s best pie, because I’m always up for expanding this list.
Especially if it involves butter.
Love pie? Forget to pin this for later!
